Peacock’s “Apples Never Fall” arrives with much anticipation, boasting an ensemble cast led by Annette Bening, Sam Neill, Jake Lacy, and Alison Brie, and based on a thriller novel by Liane Moriarty, known for “Big Little Lies.” However, despite its stellar lineup and promising premise, the series fails to fully captivate audiences, ultimately delivering a middling experience.
At the heart of “Apples Never Fall” lies the mystery surrounding Joy Delaney’s (Annette Bening) sudden disappearance, sending shockwaves through her family. As the Delaney siblings embark on a quest to uncover the truth, they delve into the complexities of their upbringing and the secrets hidden beneath their seemingly perfect facade. Flashbacks reveal a tangled web of resentments and misunderstandings, painting a vivid portrait of a family on the brink of collapse.
The series excels in portraying the intricate dynamics within the Delaney clan, with each character bringing depth and nuance to their roles. Bening shines as Joy, a woman grappling with the sacrifices she’s made for her family, while Neill delivers a poignant performance as Stan, the patriarch harboring his own demons. The chemistry among the cast members is palpable, drawing viewers into the intricate web of relationships that define the Delaneys.
However, despite its strong character-driven narrative, “Apples Never Fall” struggles to find its footing in terms of world-building and atmosphere. Set in a generic upper-middle-class suburb of West Palm Beach, Florida, the series lacks the richly detailed backdrop that elevated similar dramas like “Big Little Lies.” The Delaneys’ relationship with their community feels underdeveloped, detracting from the overall immersion in the story.
Moreover, the series’ attempts at humor and suspense often fall short, failing to elicit the intended impact. While certain moments, particularly those involving the enigmatic Savannah (Georgia Flood), provide levity, the overall tone remains restrained, lacking the tension and urgency needed to fully engage viewers.